Scarf or baby carrier backpack: Which is better to carry your baby?

Which method is best to carry the baby: sling or baby carrier backpack? As a new mother it is normal to ask yourself this question and want an answer. However, there is no single answer. Although both proposals establish close contact with the baby, what works for some families does not work for others.

Both the sling and the baby carrier are versatile carrying options that distribute the weight between the shoulders, back and waist of the carrier and that provide freedom of movement to this. Therefore, they share many characteristics, but they differ in some very important ones. Know the advantages and disadvantages of each of them.

The similarities

Let's talk first about similarities of these methods baby carriers, of the advantages and disadvantages they offer compared to other traditional methods of carrying the baby with us. Because they have them and they are key to deciding whether or not to bid by one of these methods:

• Mobility. They provide freedom of movement by allowing the baby to be carried close while we carry out activities such as walking, shopping or doing household chores without the need for push a stroller.
• Link. Carrying the baby close to the body establishes a closer contact that can favor attachment and provide the child with calm.
• Versatile: allow carrying both on the back and on the front
• The weight. Carrying is symmetrical with both methods, distributing the weight between the shoulders, back and waist. Even so, carrying a baby for long periods of time can cause back and shoulder strain for the carrier, especially if it is not properly adjusted.
• Hot. Although soft and breathable materials are used for their manufacture, depending on the weather these methods can provide excess heat to both the baby and the wearer.
• Comfort. This is a subjective term for mothers and fathers as well as for the babies themselves. Some may feel uncomfortable or restricted in the backpack, which can lead to irritability.
• Security. Carrying with both methods is safe as long as one is well advised.

Scarf vs baby carrier backpack

Now yes, let's analyze what differentiates each of these methods, what can make us opt for one or the other depending on our needs and those of the baby. And nothing better than a short description of both to know their advantages and disadvantages:

the scarf

The scarf is generally made with elastic fabric or quality bamboo. It does not have a preset shape, it has to be assembled point by point by the carrier, which allows a better adaptation to the baby's body as it grows.

This baby carrier system is therefore one of the more versatile and moldable that exists. It does require, however, a little practice to place it the first few times and it is advisable to have good advice in this regard to do it correctly.

The backpack

Unlike the scarf, the baby carrier backpack does have a pre-established shape designed with ergonomic supports and adjustable straps to adapt to both the baby and the adult who carries it. This guarantees the comfort and safety of both the baby and the wearer.

The backpack respects an appropriate posture for the development of the baby and is easier to use or does not require as much practice, however it is less mouldable. The baby carriers have weight and age limits which is essential to respect.

Conclusion

Scarf or baby carrier backpack: Which one is better to carry your baby? Now yes, after analyzing what they share and what differentiates these methods, we answer this question that we asked ourselves at the beginning.

In general, the wrap is the best method from birth to six months or until the baby weighs around 8 or 9 kilograms. Afterwards, baby carriers offer many advantages as long as their recommendations and limitations are taken into account. The most important thing in both cases, however, is to make sure you use them properly and safely.